Author: Antony Barone Kolenc
Publisher: Loyola Press
Age Range: 11- 16
This a great book. It contains all the features of a classic story for young teens – a mystery, a boy’s dorm, skulking around a castle in the middle of the night, shadowy figures walking in the woods, a lovely pretty girl who lives up the hill in the convent and some edgy fight scenes. The characters are all recognizable too – there’s the villain, the bully kid and the scared kid, and the hero of course. And what could be better than the premise that drives the story – our hero has lost his memory! Will he ever find his family, or his home?
Honestly, you can’t go wrong with all of these elements coming together in Antony Barone Kolenc’s entertaining Shadow in the Dark. We open the adventure with the thunderous sound of horses bearing down on a little village. Within three paragraphs on Page One of this book, the impending peril is almost upon them. Kolenc doesn’t waste any time plunging us into the action – readers will love it!
Kolenc stated during an interview that he consulted with Professor Jen Paxton of Catholic University in Washington about monastic life in 12th Century England. Our young hero, Xan, is living in a monastery where monks are going about their daily prayers, preserving the scriptures, and taking care of orphans. While the traditional Catholic life is not a major aspect of the story, it provides the context of this story.
The story is well paced as it follows Xan and his slowly unfolding memories of home. Along the way readers learn about the humble lives of the peasants, the extravagant wealth of the masters, and the kindness of the monks and nuns. The monks that we meet provide an array of personalities – I particularly liked how Brother Andrew reveals his amazing horse riding and Knightly fighting skills at the end (a bit like Atticus Finch from To Kill a Mockingbird turns out to be a sharpshooting marksman).
Small criticisms I had were that I couldn’t remember who was who towards the end because there seems to be so many characters; younger readers might struggle with knowing what is happening, but there is enough there to get the gist of what is evolving as the story reaches its climax. There is also reference to a monk who is grumpy all the time because he self flagellates which was apparently an accepted practice at the time. This form of self-harm might be considered a bit risky for some young readers, however it is written in such a way that many young readers will not really understand the references to self-flagellation.
By story’s end Xan has grown in character and maturity. He has learnt about courage and fear, the pursuit of justice, and the power of forgiveness. Kolenc sets up the next book of this series in the final chapter when the villain escapes and we just know that this fight is not over yet. There are apparently three books written that follow Xan’s adventures with the fourth almost complete.
I would wholeheartedly recommend this book for young teens, especially boys, and only wish there were more Catholic books of this quality published to dress the shelves of Catholic school libraries and homeschools.
See and hear Antony Barone Kolenc interviewed by A.J. Cattapan HERE
See Antony Barone Kolenc read an exerpt from the book HERE
You can buy Shadow in the Dark HERE .
Homeschool and Teaching Ideas.
There is plenty here to explore. This book could complement or inspire a study of medieval life, or the lives of monks and nuns in twelfth century England. It would be great as an entry into a study on Feudal society.
- See what the 12th Century knight’s armour was like here: https://www.levantia.com.au/crusarmour.html
- And here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAizgVYZba0
- Monastries and Monks in the middle ages and plenty more about medieval times: https://www.ducksters.com/history/middle_ages_monastery.php
- This will help teachers and homeschool parents refresh their memories about monks and monasteries: https://courses.lumenlearning.com/atd-herkimer-westerncivilization/chapter/the-rise-of-the-monasteries/
- Some free resources about monks and more: https://medievaleurope.mrdonn.org/bishops.html and https://medievaleurope.mrdonn.org/monks.html
- Feudal system for 13- or 14-year-olds: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUzRNp7OucQ&t=4s andhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yq3q7KMlvw0
There are so many great ways to teach from this book.
- Ask older students to explore the themes from the book at the local library or online: knights (armour, weapons, duties), monks and monasteries (daily life of a monk, duties of a monk, lifestyle of a monk), life for peasants and lords in 12th Century England.
- I recall teaching a class of 13- and 14-year-olds about the middle ages and they made short films in small groups – complete with costumes, setting, storyline etc.
- Sewing: design and sew up a monk’s or nun’s habit from the middle ages
- Art: paint/draw/sculpt something relevant to the story – the monastery, the various characters at work or prayer, the boys in the dorm, the fight scene, the lords and ladies, the peasants at work.
- Design: draw a map-like layout of the peasant village with castle nearby; don’t forget to show which way is North, and a nearby supply of water and where the farming fields are; is there a place for people to gather together – a church?
- Design the monastery complete with thick walls, bell tower, dorms, kitchen, stables, chapel, cells for the monks, landscaped grounds with lawns and fountains, secret tunnels and other interesting features
- Visual design: create a graphic novel representation of a scene from the novel. This might be a group project. Create a different cover for the book: why have you used these colours, images, perspective, placement of elements etc.
- For younger students you might have some fun with imagining yourself in the story – how do you describe to Xan where you come from (computers, mobile phones, cars, TV etc). Or imagine you are one of the boys trying to hide your true identity having come from the future – write a short story about it. Imagine you could bring Xan into the future for a day.
- Religion: describe/explore the different prayers that the monk’s say. How is being a monk different today from the past. (This would need some scaffolding from the teacher). Who was Saint Benedict?
- Virtues: courage, faith, pursuit of justice and truth. I would be asking students to reflect on how they might act if the same thing happened to them – what if you lost your memory and woke up in a monastery/convent? How could you show courage/faith/ the pursuit of truth (a great imaginative story here). Try to recall a time you needed to show courage to stand up for what it right.